Wednesday, April 25, 2012
A New O Canada. Why?
Messing around with a national anthem is one of those things in music that's better left alone by most. for better or worse it sounds how it sounds, and that's just the way it is. Spicing things up tends not to end well, and I'm sorry to say that seems to be what happened to Daylight For Deadeyes here.
I appreciate where they're coming from even if I don't agree. I don't remember ever being bored by O Canada, but if you were, fine. And we live in a free country, so go ahead and take a crack at making it a bit better. But that free country thing, it kind of cuts both ways. So I hope you understand that even after a few listens, I still prefer Oh Canada as it was.
Your version isn't completely horrible. I've watched far too many sporting events for it to be the worst thing I've ever heard. I'll even grant you that what you've done "embodies the band's rock feel but still stays true to the original" as the article says, I guess. But I can't shake the feeling that this rendition would be the perfect one if the aim wasn't so much to honour our nation as to sell cars or cheap beer. Come on, tell me you can't see Molson slapping hockey highlights and pictures of lakes and mountains over top of this thing. It just sounds so...so...gimmicky.
Maybe it's just me, so I'll put it to the rest of you. Should O Canada really sound like this from now on?
I appreciate where they're coming from even if I don't agree. I don't remember ever being bored by O Canada, but if you were, fine. And we live in a free country, so go ahead and take a crack at making it a bit better. But that free country thing, it kind of cuts both ways. So I hope you understand that even after a few listens, I still prefer Oh Canada as it was.
Your version isn't completely horrible. I've watched far too many sporting events for it to be the worst thing I've ever heard. I'll even grant you that what you've done "embodies the band's rock feel but still stays true to the original" as the article says, I guess. But I can't shake the feeling that this rendition would be the perfect one if the aim wasn't so much to honour our nation as to sell cars or cheap beer. Come on, tell me you can't see Molson slapping hockey highlights and pictures of lakes and mountains over top of this thing. It just sounds so...so...gimmicky.
Maybe it's just me, so I'll put it to the rest of you. Should O Canada really sound like this from now on?
Labels:
music
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

6 comments:
O Canada gives me chills every time I hear it and I'm not even Canadian. I think it's the most beautiful of the anthems (at least the ones I've heard).
However, have you heard some of the ways the Star Spangled Banner is abused? I cringe but I wouldn't like to resort to censorship. I'd say keep the original as the "official" anthem for State occasions and the Olympics and otherwise let the whirling dervishes whirl.
Hope you two are doing well.
I certainly have no problem with the fact that they did this, I just personally don't see the need. I'm glad we live in a place where folks are free to mess with the anthem and I'm free to not like it. I wouldn't want it any other way.
We're both doing well. Keeping busy, but doing just fine. Hope you are, too.
If you 'The Little Drummer Boy' by Sean Quigley,you will see that Daylight for Deadeyes copied Sean's video(which can be seen on Youtube).So I'll say it again...these guys stole their video idea from a 16yr old kid who has real talent.
I guess this band thought they would create the same buzz as Sean...but fell horribly short.
Sean Quigleys video:A drummer putting a rock twist to a classic carol with video shots from across Canada with people holding signs saying Merry Christmas.
Daylight for Deadeye's video:A drummer putting a rock twist to our Nation's Anthem with video shots from across Canada with people holding our flag.
You guys do the math....
Yup...Richard's right.This video is STOLEN
If you 'The Little Drummer Boy' by Sean Quigley,you will see that Daylight for Deadeyes copied Sean's video(which can be seen on Youtube).So I'll say it again...these guys stole their video idea from a 16yr old kid who has real talent.
I guess this band thought they would create the same buzz as Sean...but fell horribly short.
Post a Comment