Monday, August 25, 2008
Only Got A 3 Inch Tool
I'm not so sure that this would be my first line of defense if I werethis guy, but hey, I guess you've gotta do whatever you think's gonna get you off...so to speak.
A Texas doctor on trial for indecent exposure claimed that he couldn't be guilty of flashing an undercover cop because, well, there would be no point in doing so when you've only got a 2.8 inch penis that nobody would be able to see. The argument failed and he was found guilty, but there's no word on whether he'll be spending any time in the pokey. Come on, you would have made that joke too and you know it. And yes, the fact that the man's lawyers were named Dick and Neal is duely noted.
So now it's time to take an informal 2.8 inch poll. What's worse: being found guilty and having a flashing conviction on your public record, or having it be known as a matter of public record that you have admitted to needing a microscope every time you need to take a piss? I think I'm leaning towards being guilty because that kind of thing can really mess up your life, but on the other hand I'm sure the jokes and stares would get old really fast.
A Texas doctor on trial for indecent exposure claimed that he couldn't be guilty of flashing an undercover cop because, well, there would be no point in doing so when you've only got a 2.8 inch penis that nobody would be able to see. The argument failed and he was found guilty, but there's no word on whether he'll be spending any time in the pokey. Come on, you would have made that joke too and you know it. And yes, the fact that the man's lawyers were named Dick and Neal is duely noted.
So now it's time to take an informal 2.8 inch poll. What's worse: being found guilty and having a flashing conviction on your public record, or having it be known as a matter of public record that you have admitted to needing a microscope every time you need to take a piss? I think I'm leaning towards being guilty because that kind of thing can really mess up your life, but on the other hand I'm sure the jokes and stares would get old really fast.
Sunday, August 24, 2008
Amazing Grace
I feel like I've just been given a slap in the face by fate for entitling this post the way I did.
I just found out this morning that my grandma passed away. She'd been sick for a while, and I didn't know how much longer she'd make it. But it still doesn't make the freight train of news any lighter.
God she was a tough woman. For the past four years, she'd been battling with various ailments, and she always bounced back. I joked that she was a Timex watch. She'd take a licking and keep on ticking.
I know she went quickly and I guess she went peacefully. She was all alone in the hospital when she passed away. She sent her husband out to get himself something to eat, and during that brief time when he wasn't there, she went. Mom and dad just got there after, and sat with her a while. they said it looked like she was just sleeping. I hope it was peaceful. She didn't need to suffer anymore.
This whole thing makes me think of a funny thought I had when I was a kid. Her name is Grace. So, whenever I'd here the song "Amazing Grace," I thought they'd made the song for my grandma. Yep, I'm a loser kid. I'd sit there and think somebody really liked Grandma and wonder who it was and what Grandma had done to make them so happy.
When we were kids, she was always around. She lived right next door to mom and dad, so she'd often babysit. She'd invite us over for supper and ask us how we were doing. She usually had something cute or funny to say. She just had her 86th birthday, so I guess she had a pretty good life. I called her on her birthday, and we had a good conversation. She asked me if anyone had figured out how smart I was, i.e. had I found a job. I said no, and she said, "Then I'll have to give some people a kick in the pants." Man that made me laugh. I'm glad I called her on her birthday, even if I couldn't make it home. Things aren't going to be the same for a long time.
I don't feel like I'm doing a good job of this at all. Maybe I should stop before I just start babbling without any focus. Goodbye Grandma, we'll miss you. I know you didn't want us to be sad, but we'll still all miss you.
I just found out this morning that my grandma passed away. She'd been sick for a while, and I didn't know how much longer she'd make it. But it still doesn't make the freight train of news any lighter.
God she was a tough woman. For the past four years, she'd been battling with various ailments, and she always bounced back. I joked that she was a Timex watch. She'd take a licking and keep on ticking.
I know she went quickly and I guess she went peacefully. She was all alone in the hospital when she passed away. She sent her husband out to get himself something to eat, and during that brief time when he wasn't there, she went. Mom and dad just got there after, and sat with her a while. they said it looked like she was just sleeping. I hope it was peaceful. She didn't need to suffer anymore.
This whole thing makes me think of a funny thought I had when I was a kid. Her name is Grace. So, whenever I'd here the song "Amazing Grace," I thought they'd made the song for my grandma. Yep, I'm a loser kid. I'd sit there and think somebody really liked Grandma and wonder who it was and what Grandma had done to make them so happy.
When we were kids, she was always around. She lived right next door to mom and dad, so she'd often babysit. She'd invite us over for supper and ask us how we were doing. She usually had something cute or funny to say. She just had her 86th birthday, so I guess she had a pretty good life. I called her on her birthday, and we had a good conversation. She asked me if anyone had figured out how smart I was, i.e. had I found a job. I said no, and she said, "Then I'll have to give some people a kick in the pants." Man that made me laugh. I'm glad I called her on her birthday, even if I couldn't make it home. Things aren't going to be the same for a long time.
I don't feel like I'm doing a good job of this at all. Maybe I should stop before I just start babbling without any focus. Goodbye Grandma, we'll miss you. I know you didn't want us to be sad, but we'll still all miss you.
Friday, August 22, 2008
A Dangerous Dog Toy
I just read a horrible story on this blog about a dangerous dog toy. If you really want your heart ripped out, watch the videos in this post. What a horrible accident.
I guess Four Paws Inc. has been at this for a few years. They have a dog ball called the pimple ball with bell. (Item #20227-001, UPC Code 0 4566320227 9). It has a hole in each end, supposedly to prevent the creation of a vacuum while the dog is chewing on the toy. But they haven't opened up the one hole fully, so some dogs get their tongue sucked into the ball, and some dogs have had to have their tongues amputated! Oh what a horrible thing to have happen!
They apparently apologized to this guy and explained the problem and said they didn't know about this before, but the guy just found out that they have known for three years.
So for anyone out there with a dog, just a little warning about that toy. And it'll be intresting to see how this story plays out.
I guess Four Paws Inc. has been at this for a few years. They have a dog ball called the pimple ball with bell. (Item #20227-001, UPC Code 0 4566320227 9). It has a hole in each end, supposedly to prevent the creation of a vacuum while the dog is chewing on the toy. But they haven't opened up the one hole fully, so some dogs get their tongue sucked into the ball, and some dogs have had to have their tongues amputated! Oh what a horrible thing to have happen!
They apparently apologized to this guy and explained the problem and said they didn't know about this before, but the guy just found out that they have known for three years.
So for anyone out there with a dog, just a little warning about that toy. And it'll be intresting to see how this story plays out.
Goodbye, Chicken!
Here's an event I'm glad I never saw when I was in Quebec. In the town of Thetford mines, there has been an event for the past few labour days where the organizers draw lines on the ground, chop a chicken's head off, and people make bets on where the body's final resting place will be. Ok, why don't we start bear-baiting while we're at it? Of course, PETA is protesting.
Now, if they're going to protest something, at least I understand this one just because it seems pretty evil to enjoy an animal's last moments. But the guy who started this whole thing makes a good point. If you eat meat, it doesn't appear out of the blue. The animal has to be killed by someone.
Just one thing, PETA, While you're protesting, for the love of Pete, please don't compare the chicken to Tim McLean, would ya?
Now, if they're going to protest something, at least I understand this one just because it seems pretty evil to enjoy an animal's last moments. But the guy who started this whole thing makes a good point. If you eat meat, it doesn't appear out of the blue. The animal has to be killed by someone.
Just one thing, PETA, While you're protesting, for the love of Pete, please don't compare the chicken to Tim McLean, would ya?
Thoughts On "The First Lady Of The Seeing Eye"
Well, Jill is going to smile because I finished the second book she recommended, "The First Lady of the Seeing Eye". Sadly, there was no mention of Juno, not by name anyway. The empty harness was mentioned, but that's it. But I did learn a lot of stuff I never intended to.
First off, good lord I'm glad I didn't grow up in that era. I don't think I would have survived it. I would have gotten so enraged I probably would have given myself an aneurysm. I can't even imagine not having proper mobility training. It seemed they handed out white canes with no teaching. It was just like, "here. Put this stick in front of you and maybe you won't hit stuff." So at the time, there were a bunch of blinks shuffling about, falling down holes, and not crossing streets on their own. They had to be led around by the nose anyway, only now they also held a stick.
I know one reason they didn't cross streets on their own back then was, gasp, the traffic light wasn't invented or broadly used yet! No goddamn wonder they didn't try and cross streets. it would have been pure mayhem! I mean, I know there weren't as many motorized vehicles, but I think horses' hoofs would have been just as deadly. I can't imagine standing at a street corner with my cane and going "tap tap tap" waiting for some kind soul to lead me like a sheep across the street. Even in the 1940's, that was still going on. There is one plaza where I wait for assistance because it's a goddamn zoo, and now, every time I stand there, all I can think is "tap tap tap."
Back then, the guide dog really increased someone's freedom exponentially. I mean, I'm not going to downplay the feeling of freedom I have when walking with the Trixter because I can move so much faster and more fluidly, but before her, I could still get around. It was just slower and less graceful. But back then, if you didn't have a dog, your fate was to be treated like "an American express parcel" as Morris Frank put it. You would be taken somewhere and then left there until you could be picked up. You would have to hire people to lead you somewhere, and if they decided to screw you over, well, that was that. You were helpless.
Does anyone remember those days? Did blind people really stand at street corners tapping their canes and begging to be helped across the street? Was that a common practice? I have to wonder if it was, since two different books mentioned it.
I think guide dog handlers, especially in the states, owe a lot to Morris Frank and Dorothy Eustis. She had the realization that guide dogs would be useless if they couldn't go into any buildings or ride buses, and he dit a whole hell of a lot of advocacy to get access for guide dogs. He had to fight a lot of battles that we just don't have to fight now, and be the first one to educate people about all things guide dog. I mean, we all have to do a lot of educating, but people really had noone else to ask back then. It was him, spending years of his life on the road, speaking all over the country, who explained things for the first time.
Not only that, but the school showed a lot of other schools how to do this guide dog training thing over here. Morris Frank was their Chuck, too! Jesus, I wish I had half his ambition.
Some of the stuff he said really seemed overdone, though. Maybe it's the different temperament, lab vs. German shepherd, but I would never get off a ship with Trixie after traveling from Switzerland to the U.S. when we were a new team and then expect her to successfully cross an insane highway-like street with seemingly no traffic control. Trixie's awesome, but she's not half the trooper that he makes Buddy out to be. I wasn't there, so I can't say if he added in some hearts and flowers to help the school out, but it sure makes me wonder.
One thing I noticed was that in his time, the dogs were trained to fetch things that we dropped. I know GDB used to do that long before my time, but I guess it was phased out. I think old Trix would try and take advantage of that, bending over to fetch...some crumbs of food for herself.
It was definitely an interesting read, and made me realize how lucky we are these days with regard to access and the guide woof. I would never imagine leaving Trixie in the baggage car of a train. I know if I read this book before Trixie, I wouldn't have gotten nearly as much out of it as I do now. It's definitely interesting to get a historical perspective.
First off, good lord I'm glad I didn't grow up in that era. I don't think I would have survived it. I would have gotten so enraged I probably would have given myself an aneurysm. I can't even imagine not having proper mobility training. It seemed they handed out white canes with no teaching. It was just like, "here. Put this stick in front of you and maybe you won't hit stuff." So at the time, there were a bunch of blinks shuffling about, falling down holes, and not crossing streets on their own. They had to be led around by the nose anyway, only now they also held a stick.
I know one reason they didn't cross streets on their own back then was, gasp, the traffic light wasn't invented or broadly used yet! No goddamn wonder they didn't try and cross streets. it would have been pure mayhem! I mean, I know there weren't as many motorized vehicles, but I think horses' hoofs would have been just as deadly. I can't imagine standing at a street corner with my cane and going "tap tap tap" waiting for some kind soul to lead me like a sheep across the street. Even in the 1940's, that was still going on. There is one plaza where I wait for assistance because it's a goddamn zoo, and now, every time I stand there, all I can think is "tap tap tap."
Back then, the guide dog really increased someone's freedom exponentially. I mean, I'm not going to downplay the feeling of freedom I have when walking with the Trixter because I can move so much faster and more fluidly, but before her, I could still get around. It was just slower and less graceful. But back then, if you didn't have a dog, your fate was to be treated like "an American express parcel" as Morris Frank put it. You would be taken somewhere and then left there until you could be picked up. You would have to hire people to lead you somewhere, and if they decided to screw you over, well, that was that. You were helpless.
Does anyone remember those days? Did blind people really stand at street corners tapping their canes and begging to be helped across the street? Was that a common practice? I have to wonder if it was, since two different books mentioned it.
I think guide dog handlers, especially in the states, owe a lot to Morris Frank and Dorothy Eustis. She had the realization that guide dogs would be useless if they couldn't go into any buildings or ride buses, and he dit a whole hell of a lot of advocacy to get access for guide dogs. He had to fight a lot of battles that we just don't have to fight now, and be the first one to educate people about all things guide dog. I mean, we all have to do a lot of educating, but people really had noone else to ask back then. It was him, spending years of his life on the road, speaking all over the country, who explained things for the first time.
Not only that, but the school showed a lot of other schools how to do this guide dog training thing over here. Morris Frank was their Chuck, too! Jesus, I wish I had half his ambition.
Some of the stuff he said really seemed overdone, though. Maybe it's the different temperament, lab vs. German shepherd, but I would never get off a ship with Trixie after traveling from Switzerland to the U.S. when we were a new team and then expect her to successfully cross an insane highway-like street with seemingly no traffic control. Trixie's awesome, but she's not half the trooper that he makes Buddy out to be. I wasn't there, so I can't say if he added in some hearts and flowers to help the school out, but it sure makes me wonder.
One thing I noticed was that in his time, the dogs were trained to fetch things that we dropped. I know GDB used to do that long before my time, but I guess it was phased out. I think old Trix would try and take advantage of that, bending over to fetch...some crumbs of food for herself.
It was definitely an interesting read, and made me realize how lucky we are these days with regard to access and the guide woof. I would never imagine leaving Trixie in the baggage car of a train. I know if I read this book before Trixie, I wouldn't have gotten nearly as much out of it as I do now. It's definitely interesting to get a historical perspective.
More Ways To Help Holly
Remember Holly? Well, she's still struggling along, and she's also moved. I hope her new community is a little more helpful.
At any rate, she now has a Cafepress store where you can buy everything from bumper stickers to mugs to mouse pads to hoodies. I'm not a big fan of how much money Cafe Press takes from each purchase, but the more of us buy, the more money she'll get. I might get a travel mug. So there ya go. If you like the design, help her out.
At any rate, she now has a Cafepress store where you can buy everything from bumper stickers to mugs to mouse pads to hoodies. I'm not a big fan of how much money Cafe Press takes from each purchase, but the more of us buy, the more money she'll get. I might get a travel mug. So there ya go. If you like the design, help her out.
Isn't This A Little Extreme?
This is insane. First we have fire marshals cuffing people for swearing in Wal-Mart, and now people are being taken downtown for overdue library books. What's going on?
Blackened And Blue Angel
Thursday, August 21, 2008
R.I.P. My Stupid Computer
Well, it's official. my limping computer can't limp anymore. It is a large paperweight. Today, it shut off three times while I was trying to click links. The third time, it would not turn on. the other times, I had to reach back and hit the direct power switch that supplied the juice to the power supply to get it to remember how to turn on. The last time that happened, the bios forgot everything it had remembered and I had to press f1 to continue. After that, it shut off for the last time.
I made the mistake of going to get laundry, and when I came back, my computer would only power up for about half a second. Then it would power back off again. I think it's official. It's time to say it's gone. I was hoping it would wait until June of 09 when I came due for ADP, but that's not to be.
I should have known it wasn't going to make it. Let's go through the times I have cursed this beast from hell. I had it less than a month when the scanner broke, and the fan whined like a jet engine, sending it back to the repair shop, such as it was. Four months later, it blew a regulator. Do four-month old computers blow regulators? Well, mine did. It dragged its arse along for a while, until it consumed about 12 hours' worth of Steve's email, and I noticed other files going missing. I dragged my feet until I finally took it to a repair-shop. For a while, I thought it was healed! It seemed to be all good...until...August of that year when I had to take it to another shop, which profoundly sucked. Amazingly, the stupid thing hummed along until February of 2008 when I got it new ram. Again, I thought it was cured. Not so much. All of this was for nothing. Now, it appears to be dead, and Steve and Trixie's second lover drank a toast to the now deceased computer.
Anyway, now that everyone's thoroughly bored, my only point I had was posts may be a little thin since we'll be sharing one computer. Steve, le'ts hope I don't manage to break yours too, like what happened to you when you were using my old, good computer while yours was dead.
I made the mistake of going to get laundry, and when I came back, my computer would only power up for about half a second. Then it would power back off again. I think it's official. It's time to say it's gone. I was hoping it would wait until June of 09 when I came due for ADP, but that's not to be.
I should have known it wasn't going to make it. Let's go through the times I have cursed this beast from hell. I had it less than a month when the scanner broke, and the fan whined like a jet engine, sending it back to the repair shop, such as it was. Four months later, it blew a regulator. Do four-month old computers blow regulators? Well, mine did. It dragged its arse along for a while, until it consumed about 12 hours' worth of Steve's email, and I noticed other files going missing. I dragged my feet until I finally took it to a repair-shop. For a while, I thought it was healed! It seemed to be all good...until...August of that year when I had to take it to another shop, which profoundly sucked. Amazingly, the stupid thing hummed along until February of 2008 when I got it new ram. Again, I thought it was cured. Not so much. All of this was for nothing. Now, it appears to be dead, and Steve and Trixie's second lover drank a toast to the now deceased computer.
Anyway, now that everyone's thoroughly bored, my only point I had was posts may be a little thin since we'll be sharing one computer. Steve, le'ts hope I don't manage to break yours too, like what happened to you when you were using my old, good computer while yours was dead.
Brenden The Giant
Wow. You know how I complain about being too short? Here's a kid who is too tall. I mean way, way, way the hell too tall. This 12-year-old kid is over seven feet tall! He doesn't fit in a SUV. And he's the only kid like this. His genes decided to play some flip-flops and because the 12th pair of chromosomes is all messed up, he's growing out of control.
Hey Brenden Adams, can our pituitaries have a chat? Yours can tell mine how to get off its behind, even though I wouldn't grow anyway, and mine can tell yours to slow down a little.
Hey Brenden Adams, can our pituitaries have a chat? Yours can tell mine how to get off its behind, even though I wouldn't grow anyway, and mine can tell yours to slow down a little.
Wednesday, August 20, 2008
That's A Good Noise!
The thing I have to say about this post is woohoo! I would like to say it as loudly as possible.
Some true geniuses over at Lotus Engineering have come up with a brilliant solution to the problem of hybrid cars being silent pedestrian-pulverizers. They want to install a waterproof speaker on the outside of the front of the car. When the car is running on electric mode, it will emit a sound that sounds like, well, a car, and will change it based on the car's speed of movement!
Yea! Simplicity! That rocks! I am so thankful that there are wonderful people out there who have brains that are still working.
In case any blinks want to see the video referenced in the story, it is actually here.
Finally! Something to scream about in a happy way!
Some true geniuses over at Lotus Engineering have come up with a brilliant solution to the problem of hybrid cars being silent pedestrian-pulverizers. They want to install a waterproof speaker on the outside of the front of the car. When the car is running on electric mode, it will emit a sound that sounds like, well, a car, and will change it based on the car's speed of movement!
Yea! Simplicity! That rocks! I am so thankful that there are wonderful people out there who have brains that are still working.
In case any blinks want to see the video referenced in the story, it is actually here.
Finally! Something to scream about in a happy way!
I Didn't Want That Kind Of Travel Bug
Last night, I talked to another dude who does geocaching, and somehow we got talking about my theories on geocaching gone bad. He, like W.S.g, says he's never found anything malicious in a geocache. Wow! I'm truly amazed! Maybe there's hope for us after all. But he did tell me a gross story that happened to him. he said he has opened geocaches where people have left food in them. Now the food has gone bad, and the box has become an ant colony. *gag!*
Man, some people just don't think. I'm sure they mean well. but...dude, there's a reason why we keep food in a fridge. If it's just hangin' out there, it attracts bugs.
Man, some people just don't think. I'm sure they mean well. but...dude, there's a reason why we keep food in a fridge. If it's just hangin' out there, it attracts bugs.
Cleanup In Aisle 5
The funniest thing aboutthisisn't that somebody thinks Northern Peaks is a good name for a porn channel or even that part of the draw is that much of it's programming will be made in Canada thus ensuring that for the first time ever somebody will actually watch a Canadian movie. Oh no. What makes this so great is this sentence:
The he in question is station president Shaun Donnelly, a man I never want to go shopping with.
Seriously, where did that line come from? Not sure about the rest of you, but when I'm standing in the produce section picking out cucumbers, the last thing I want is some semi-famous woman I jerked off to the night before standing next to me, looking from me to the shelf, me to the shelf, sizing both of us up. I know she's thinking "ok, I could take him home and fuck him, but he's nowhere near as big as these things and I don't have to buy them dinner first. Hell, they are dinner."
And let's say you can get over that part. What kind of conversation can you possibly strike up with this woman.
"You know, I really enjoy your work. In fact I enjoy it so much that I think you should pay for part of my wrist surgery. Oh by the way, you dropped your uterus."
I can't imagine that being the stuff of anybody's fantasy life, at least not anybody who gets out of the house much. Then again, the more time somebody spends inside thinking about this kind of thing the more likely that person is to order the station, so maybe he's on to something after all and the crazy one is me.
"Canadians love watching Canadian adult content," he sad. "I think it's the fantasy of it that it's somebody you can actually run into in the grocery store."
The he in question is station president Shaun Donnelly, a man I never want to go shopping with.
Seriously, where did that line come from? Not sure about the rest of you, but when I'm standing in the produce section picking out cucumbers, the last thing I want is some semi-famous woman I jerked off to the night before standing next to me, looking from me to the shelf, me to the shelf, sizing both of us up. I know she's thinking "ok, I could take him home and fuck him, but he's nowhere near as big as these things and I don't have to buy them dinner first. Hell, they are dinner."
And let's say you can get over that part. What kind of conversation can you possibly strike up with this woman.
"You know, I really enjoy your work. In fact I enjoy it so much that I think you should pay for part of my wrist surgery. Oh by the way, you dropped your uterus."
I can't imagine that being the stuff of anybody's fantasy life, at least not anybody who gets out of the house much. Then again, the more time somebody spends inside thinking about this kind of thing the more likely that person is to order the station, so maybe he's on to something after all and the crazy one is me.
Where's The Crime Here?
Charlotte, NC
A 46-year-old woman said she was assaulted by a family member for moving furniture in his house without permission. The woman was a guest in her relative’s home and took it upon herself to do a little remodeling. When her relative saw what she did, he got angry and tried to push a china cabinet on her.
I would like to publicly denounce any police involvement that has already taken place or may occur at some point in this case. Speaking as a blind person with experience with unwanted redecorating, I can tell you that this person showed unbelievable restraint and should be commended, not arrested.
Original story.
How The Internet Works
I feel I need to explain this to Shakespear Feyissa, because he doesn't seem to have clue 1 about online culture. He also seems to have missed out on clue 1 when it comes to journalism ethics, but his being a lawyer makes it easier for me to understand how anything related to ethics probably went right over his head.
His full story ishere,and you can see the old article that's got him so upsethereorherein case he somehow manages to strong-arm the newspaper into taking it down.
Which brings me to how the internet works. When are people going to realize that trying to get something taken offline accomplishes nothing more than ensuring that whatever you don't want people to see will be plastered all over the web for the rest of time? It seems like such a simple concept, one that applied even before there was an internet. When you were a kid and mom and dad told you not to go into a certain drawer or to stay out of the cookie jar, what was the first thing you did when you thought you wouldn't get caught? If you were normal, you tried to get into the drawer or nip a cookie. If something is forbidden, it's tempting. That's simple human nature. And when one person who feels that he's on the wrong end of some news coverage tries to dictate to the media and the public what's forbidden, it's online human nature to put that person in his place. It's also online human nature for millions of people who didn't know your name before to learn all about it and make sure that everybody else can too. In short, if that article in the Falcon pisses you off, just think about how you're going to feel when countless blogs and news sites pick it up. Not only are you going to look like somebody who makes outlandish statements about discrimination, but you're also going to look like the whiney crazy guy who thinks he has more power than everybody else's right to a free press and historical facts.
What Shakespear Feyissa needs to understand is that what he's asking for is ridiculous. Telling a newspaper to remove a story and pretend something didn't happen is like some German guy asking the HistoryChannel to edit Hitler out of all of the war footage. Nobody would stand for it, nor should they. And they aren't going to stand for this either, but I'm sure he's already finding that out the hard way.
His full story ishere,and you can see the old article that's got him so upsethereorherein case he somehow manages to strong-arm the newspaper into taking it down.
Which brings me to how the internet works. When are people going to realize that trying to get something taken offline accomplishes nothing more than ensuring that whatever you don't want people to see will be plastered all over the web for the rest of time? It seems like such a simple concept, one that applied even before there was an internet. When you were a kid and mom and dad told you not to go into a certain drawer or to stay out of the cookie jar, what was the first thing you did when you thought you wouldn't get caught? If you were normal, you tried to get into the drawer or nip a cookie. If something is forbidden, it's tempting. That's simple human nature. And when one person who feels that he's on the wrong end of some news coverage tries to dictate to the media and the public what's forbidden, it's online human nature to put that person in his place. It's also online human nature for millions of people who didn't know your name before to learn all about it and make sure that everybody else can too. In short, if that article in the Falcon pisses you off, just think about how you're going to feel when countless blogs and news sites pick it up. Not only are you going to look like somebody who makes outlandish statements about discrimination, but you're also going to look like the whiney crazy guy who thinks he has more power than everybody else's right to a free press and historical facts.
What Shakespear Feyissa needs to understand is that what he's asking for is ridiculous. Telling a newspaper to remove a story and pretend something didn't happen is like some German guy asking the HistoryChannel to edit Hitler out of all of the war footage. Nobody would stand for it, nor should they. And they aren't going to stand for this either, but I'm sure he's already finding that out the hard way.
Tuesday, August 19, 2008
Now I Know Why They Call It The Loser Cruiser
There's a reason you've always heard of a getaway car and not a getaway bus. Yeah, he didn't even steal a school bus or something. After stealing beer from a convenience store, he waited outside the store at the bus stop for the bus.
Dude, I think you would have been better off using your getaway feet.
Dude, I think you would have been better off using your getaway feet.
The Lights Of The Wrong Birmingham
First we had the mix-up over who Russia is at war with, and now we have something even worse. Can you believe it? Well, I give you a big mistake made by government officials of Birmingham, UK.
They sent out leaflets thanking everyone for doing such a great job in their recycling efforrts. They stamped the words "thank you Birmingham" across a photo of the Birmingham skyline. The problem was the skyline belonged to Birmingham, Alabama. They completely admit the error, and say they picked the wrong photo out of an internet archive.
Ok, I can see one person making that mistake. But I'm sure this booklet had to pass through several hands. You would think one of them would have noticed it before it hit the public.
Even worse, this is the second time the wrong picture has been used.
Yikes.
They sent out leaflets thanking everyone for doing such a great job in their recycling efforrts. They stamped the words "thank you Birmingham" across a photo of the Birmingham skyline. The problem was the skyline belonged to Birmingham, Alabama. They completely admit the error, and say they picked the wrong photo out of an internet archive.
Ok, I can see one person making that mistake. But I'm sure this booklet had to pass through several hands. You would think one of them would have noticed it before it hit the public.
Even worse, this is the second time the wrong picture has been used.
Yikes.
Stand, On The bus Ride To Work, Don't Fall Down
Ok, first we had booklets instructing folks on how to catch a bus. Now that everyone's on the bus, we need posters telling people how to remain standing while the bus moves. Wow. Lots of people get hurt in non-collision-related accidents, apparently because they lose their balance and fall over. Yeah, it sucks standing in a bus...but...signage? We need that?
May I Speak To Stupid, Please?
Wow. I have to hope that this was Christopher Kron's first burglary. That has to be the reason he would
Happy birthday Christopher. I hope you enjoy it in jail.
- ignore a really loud burglar alarm,
- walk towards the cameras while stealing only a bottle of booze,
- answer the phone,
- and when it was the security company, give his real name,
- and when he managed to get away before the police arrived, come back the next day!
Happy birthday Christopher. I hope you enjoy it in jail.
Saturday, August 16, 2008
Help Define "Service Animal"
Gees! There's not much time to respond. I just got this email, and the deadline for public comments is Monday! Ok ok ok, up on the blog she goes! I know I'm not American, but plenty of people who read this thing live in the States, so here it is.
Apparently, the definition of service animal under the ADA is up for review. The IAADP is trying to cut back on the number of false service dogs running around, as well as allow for dogs that help people with psychiatric disabilities. They are also trying to eliminate some of the confusion that's happening around some of the wording. There is a long email ahead. If you want to help by making some comments, even if the comments you want to make aren't mentioned in the email, this email gives you all the instructions. I hope this helps someone.
Tired yet? I know I am. But hey, even if people don't agree with all that stuff, at least they can still make their own feelings known. Hopefully this results in clarification, no more pets running around where they shouldn't, and everybody who has legitimate service dogs, whether owner-trained or school-trained, getting the access they deserve.
Apparently, the definition of service animal under the ADA is up for review. The IAADP is trying to cut back on the number of false service dogs running around, as well as allow for dogs that help people with psychiatric disabilities. They are also trying to eliminate some of the confusion that's happening around some of the wording. There is a long email ahead. If you want to help by making some comments, even if the comments you want to make aren't mentioned in the email, this email gives you all the instructions. I hope this helps someone.
Dear friend of the assistance dog movement,
As a spokesperson for the International Association of Assistance Dog Partners, I need your help on a matter of critical importance to the assistance dog movement in the United States.
As you may have read in Partners Forum, for seven years as IAADP’s representative, I lobbied the U.S. Department of Justice with colleagues in the Coalition of Assistance Dog Organizations (CADO), seeking a better definition of a Service Animal. We knew the ADA regulations were up for review. We wanted to end the misinterpretations and abuses of the old service animal definition. We also sought recognition for the existence of service dogs trained to perform tasks to assist people with mental as well as physical disabilities.
This summer the Department of Justice proposed their new definition and is seeking input from the public. Sources at the DOJ tell us this Public Comment phase is a crucial element in developing the Final Definition.
It is “a Numbers Game.” We need to show officials at the DOJ through public comments that MORE people are in favor of what we want, as opposed to what someone else may want.
After reading all the comments submitted to date, I realized we urgently need favorable comments on two issues in particular, to offset the comments of people who don’t want any changes to the old definition. The first and most important issue is our recommendation to eliminate the phrase “do work” and continue to uphold “task training” as the defining factor in qualifying an animal to be a service animal, something the DOJ has been doing since 2002 in their highly publicized interpretative guidance document, the “ADA Business Brief : Service Animals.” The second issue is our recommendation to remove the task example “minimal protection” from the definition due to the problems it has caused. We think fifteen years of misinterpretation and abuses due to the confusion over these phrases is enough! We only have a few more days till the Public Comment period closes on August 18th. You can do a lot to help IAADP turn the tide. It will only take you a few minutes.
If you want to submit a comment with minimal effort, please look at the Sample Comment in this email below my signature. You can just copy and paste it into the General Comment box if desired, or submit whatever part of it you feel you can support.
However, it would carry a lot more weight if you personalize your comment. Please consider adding a sentence or two at the beginning so the DOJ knows it comes from an assistance dog partner or family member or friend of someone with a task trained guide, hearing or service dog. ( Example: I have a service dog who has greatly improved my quality of life by providing balance support and performing other trained tasks to assist me in a medical crisis.)
(Example: I’m the mother of a boy with autism whose specially trained service dog performs some wonderful tasks to increase his safety and independence.)
Instructions on how to submit your Public comment follows the Sample Comment. It is very easy to do!
Those who prefer to have more information on the subject before commenting are welcome to go to
www.iaadp.org
and go to the Emergency Call to Action box and read all the information I prepared for visitors.
If you missed IAADP's first announcement of the public comment period a few weeks ago and want to read the new proposed Service Animal definition and IAADP's public comment or wish to read CADO's public comment, I will copy them into this email at the very bottom.
It would mean the world to IAADP and the assistance dog movement if you'd take a few minutes to submit a public comment before it is too late. If you did not comment on these two subjects before, you can submit another comment.
most appreciatively,
Joan
IAADP chairperson / editor
SAMPLE COMMENT
I'm writing to let you know that I support IAADP and CADO's position on the following:
Please eliminate the ambiguous phrase "DO WORK" from the new Definition to prevent years of misinterpretation. Continue to educate the public that the legal difference between a pet and a service animal is that service animals must be individually trained to perform tasks for the benefit of a disabled individual, as you have been doing in the “ADA Business Brief :Service Animals” since 2002.
In response to Question Nine, please delete the word "protection" from the definition, as the word means "aggression training" in the dog training industry. Fifteen years of misinterpretation of the task example "minimal protection" should be enough.
The Department's effort to clarify the ADA grants public access to anyone with a disabling mental or physical impairment working with a service animal having the required training is greatly appreciated.
TO SUBMIT YOUR COMMENT TO THE PUBLIC COMMENT WEBSITE ON THE ADA
1. Click on this Link.
2. Fill out the Form with your name and address.
3. Write your comment in the General Comments Box
4. Scroll to the bottom of the webpage and click on the button that says: NEXT
5. This next page lets you review your comment. If you like it, scroll down and click on SUBMIT
Now you are done!
Your support at this time for our efforts to prevent future misinterpretations of the ADA service animal definition would be a wonderful contribution to the assistance dog movement. Thank you for considering this request.
New Proposed Service Animal Definition
PART 36-NONDISCRIMINATION ON THE BASIS OF DISABILITY BY PUBLIC ACCOMMODATIONS
AND IN COMMERCIAL FACILITIES
Subpart A-General
PROPOSED DEFINITION
Service animal means any dog or other common domestic animal individually trained to do work or perform tasks for the benefit of an individual with a disability, including, but not limited
to, guiding individuals who are blind or have low vision, alerting individuals who are deaf or hard of hearing to the presence of people or sounds, providing minimal protection or rescue work, pulling a wheelchair, fetching items, assisting an individual during a seizure, retrieving medicine or the telephone, providing physical support and assistance with balance and stability to individuals with mobility disabilities, and assisting individuals, including those with cognitive
disabilities, with navigation. The term service animal includes individually trained animals that do work or perform tasks for the benefit of individuals with disabilities, including
psychiatric, cognitive, and mental disabilities. The term service animal does not include wild animals (including nonhuman primates born in captivity), reptiles, rabbits, farm animals (including any breed of horse, miniature horse, pony, pig, or goat), ferrets, amphibians, and rodents. Animals whose sole function is to provide emotional support, comfort, therapy, companionship, therapeutic benefits, or to promote emotional well-being are not service animals.
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF ASSISTANCE DOG PARTNERS
IAADP's Public Comment on the Department of Justice 2008 NPRM
Re: Revision of the ADA Service Animal Definition
Docket ID: DOJ-CRT-2008-0015
The International Association of Assistance Dog Partners (IAADP) is a cross-disability consumer advocacy organization with more than 2,000 members working with guide, hearing and service dogs. Its mission is to foster the assistance dog movement through education, advocacy and peer support.
We commend the Department of Justice for including in its revised proposed definition of service animal a number of new and
essential elements, particularly emphasis on maintaining control of the service animal in public settings and the requirement of housebreaking. As an organization committed to fostering the assistance dog movement, IAADP appreciates the Department of Justice's attempt to clarify the definition of service animal for the general population, public accommodation representatives and those working with service animals. However, IAADP believes certain issues need further clarification before being established as final rules.
In response to the NPRM published in the Federal Register on June 17th, IAADP, based on the rationale discussed below, encourages the Department of Justice to:
1. Eliminate the phrase "providing minimal protection" from the definition of service animal;
2. Eliminate the phrase "do work" from the definition because it is redundant and the example of work given in the NPRM, grounding, undermines the Department's goal of maintaining a clear distinction between specially trained service animals and those animals whose mere presence can provide emotional support, companionship or therapeutic benefits.
3. Limit the use of other species only to animals who can be trained to meet the same standards for behavior and training that assistance dogs must meet to qualify for public access.
4. Avoid placing a size or weight limit on common domestic animals such as assistance dogs.
According to the NPRM, widespread misinterpretation of the minimal protection language has been a problem for the last 15 years. The DOJ notes "Despite the Department's best efforts, the minimal protection language appears to have been misinterpreted." By continuing the use of this language, nothing will change. Since the mission of the new rules is to clarify and avoid confusion, maintenance of this phrase undermines this goal.
Minimal protection has been used by some trainers and disabled partners to justify attack and aggression training for what are claimed to be service animals. Although the Department does not agree with this interpretation, continuing to use the minimal protection phrase will foster the idea that attack and aggressive behavior are acceptable tasks performed by assistance dogs.
The justification for including minimal protection in the original definition was to guarantee the rights of those with seizure disorders to train their service dogs for seizure response and alert tasks. Since the new definition proposed by the Department includes assisting an individual during a seizure, the minimal protection language is redundant and not needed. In addition, a major function of service dogs is to help or get help not to prevent help from being given. Allowing "minimal
protection" is the antithesis of what a service dog is trained to do. Therefore, in response to Question Nine, IAADP believes that maintaining the "providing minimal protection" clause is counterproductive to the goal of the current NPRM.
IAADP applauds DOJ's categorical statement: "Animals whose sole function is to provide emotional support, comfort, therapy, companionship, therapeutic benefits, or to promote emotional well-being are not service animals."
IAADP believes it is imperative to make it clear that individuals with disabilities whose pets or companion animals have not been trained to perform tasks directly related to their disability do
not qualify as service animals. These are usually referred to as emotional support or comfort dogs when associated with a person with a psychiatric, cognitive or mental disability. Since individuals with psychiatric disabilities constitute the largest single category of Americans with disabilities, the distinction
between task training to mitigate a disability on the one hand, and mere presence on the other should be clear and consistently supported by the Department.
IAADP'S concern is with the section in the NPRM that reads:
"In contrast, the phrase 'do work' is slightly broader than 'perform tasks', and adds meaning to the definition." By
definition all work is task defined thus to say "do work" is redundant and not needed.
Another concern is the example given of a psychiatric service dog helping some individuals with dissociative identity disorder to remain grounded in time or place. By including grounding as work performed by a psychiatric service dog, the Department is providing the basis for an individual with a psychiatric disability to claim the mere presence of a dog, which helps ground him/her, meets the DOJ definition of a service animal. This reference contradicts the strong and clear statement that emotional support, companion or comfort animals do not meet the Department's definition of a service animal. It also contradicts the basic premise that a service animal performs a task to mitigate a disability. If included, this section will continue to be a source of confusion to the public, businesses and assistance dog partners. IAADP believes the reference to grounding should be eliminated, as well as the phrase "do work".
In response to Question Ten, IAADP commends the Department for recognizing the concerns expressed by many of our constituents about the use of reptiles and other species that cannot be reliably housebroken, task trained or, which by their very nature, pose a threat to public safety. Our goal is to promote the responsible use of access rights and prevent the erosion of societal tolerance for service animal teams in places of public accommodation.
In response to Question 11 concerning the size and weight of common domestic animals, IAADP endorses the current Department policy. We believe it is not the role of the government to limit disabled people's choice of what would be an effective assistance dog for them.
The size of a service animal is a matter of individual choice/necessity and may be related to the nature of the disability. Limiting size and weight would discriminate against disabled individuals who because of their height or weight and/or
the severity of their mobility impairment need to work with very large powerful dogs on strenuous tasks such as providing stability while walking, helping transfer in and out of chairs, getting up after a fall or pulling a wheelchair. IAADP recommends not placing limits on the size or weight of service animals.
With the incorporation of IAADP's recommendations in the new definitions, we feel that the current confusion and misinterpretations will be greatly mitigated to everyone's
benefit.
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the NPRM.
Ed Eames, Ph.D., President
International Association of Assistance Dog Partners
COALITION OF ASSISTANCE DOG ORGANIZATIONS
P. O. Box 1326
Sterling Heights, Michigan 48311
Phone: 586-826-3938
July 30, 2008
U.S. Department of Justice
Disability Rights Section,
Civil Rights Division
Washington DC
Docket ID: DOJ-CRT-2008-0015
RE: ADA Service Animal Definition and Regulations
Founded in 2001, the Coalition of Assistance Dog Organizations brings together the consumer advocacy organizations representing individuals with disabilities who work with guide, hearing and service dogs and two umbrella organizations for the non profit programs which train canine assistants in the USA. Guide Dog Users, Inc. has over 1000 blind and visually impaired members partnered with guide dogs. The International Association of Assistance
Dog Partners has over 2000 disabled members whose guide, hearing and service dogs are owner trained, privately trained or program trained to perform tasks to mitigate the effects of their disabilities. The Council of US Dog Guide Schools represents ten schools which specialize in the breeding and training of guide dogs. Assistance Dogs International represents more than 100 not for profit programs which train assistance dogs for children and adults with physical and mental disabilities. As a coalition, CADO adopts and promotes its positions through seeking input from its diverse membership and by providing a platform for many like minded individuals to speak with one voice when this is necessary to achieve consensus and change.
CADO members are united in the desire to preserve the public access rights granted by the Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA) for the next generation. Collectively we remain deeply concerned about the abuses of the ADA taking place due to accidental or intentional misinterpretation of the original Service Animal definition.
After careful review of the Notice of Proposed Rule Making issued June 17, 2008, CADO commends the Disability Rights section in the Civil Rights division of the U.S. Department of Justice for a number of the changes in wording that have been proposed and for the unequivocal statement that makes clearer the fact that emotional support animals and companion animals are not service animals. We support the Department's decision to incorporate policies from its 1996 and 2002 interpretative guidance documents into the ADA regulation ( 28 CFR 36.302c) which will give these policies greater standing legally as well as educationally. We welcome the addition of the housebreaking requirement and the emphasis on keeping an animal under control in the newly proposed definition of a service animal. However we believe the effort to end the misinterpretations of the definition of a service animal falls short of achieving the intended goal in several areas. Below, CADO will address the three questions posed in the NPRM pertaining to service animals as well as another important issue we strongly encourage the DOJ to reconsider, the retention of “Do Work” in the proposed new definition because of the example of it that was given in the NPRM.
QUESTION NINE: Should the Department clarify the phrase "providing minimal protection" in the definition or remove it?
CADO is strongly opposed to the retention of the words "minimal protection" or any mention of “protection.” Protection language is often incorrectly interpreted by individuals and training programs alike as a license to train aggression related protection behaviors.
In the NPRM the DOJ itself makes the point that despite its best efforts, the phrase continues to be misinterpreted. While the Department may not condone attack or aggression training, it will certainly continue until the word “protection” is removed from the definition. This word has very specific meaning within the dog training industry. It is the word which means aggression training.
In the NPRM, the Department said it tried to clarify "minimal protection" in 2002 with the example "alerting and protecting a person having a seizure," in its interpretative guidance document, "Business Brief; Service Animals." Unfortunately this clarification has also been misinterpreted as sanctioning protection training. CADO believes the new task example cited in the proposed Definition, "assistance during a seizure" is a much more accurate description of tasks required to accomplish the goal of ensuring the inclusion of people who have a disabling seizure disorder. This new task example, "assistance during a seizure," in addition to other new tasks in the proposed definition , namely retrieving medicine or the telephone, providing physical support to assist with balance and stability to individuals with mobility disabilities, and assisting individuals, including those with cognitive disabilities, with navigation is clear and concise. Collectively these new task examples have made the old task example, “minimal protection and rescue work” unnecessary.
In conclusion, CADO respectfully requests that the Department give further consideration to eliminating this misleading language in the service animal definition. Fifteen years of confusion, debates and ongoing misinterpretation of the "minimal protection," language is more than enough. It is time to remove this phrase and end the confusion and damage that it creates.
QUESTION TEN: Should the Department eliminate certain species from the definition of "service animal"? If so, please provide comment on the Department’s use of the phrase "common domestic animal" and on its choice of which types of animals to exclude.
CADO sincerely thanks the DOJ for responding to the many issues raised concerning the use of species which may pose a threat to public safety or which can't be housebroken or task trained. We believe the continuing use of such species will have an eroding impact on societal tolerance for service animal teams in public places.
CADO does not oppose the use of another species if, and only if, the animal can meet the same or equivalent standards for behavior and training that assistance dogs must meet to qualify for public access. This would represent a far less discriminatory approach. We request that the DOJ consider adopting CADO's 2005 Minimum Behavior and Training Standards for all service animals, or that similar guidelines be drafted. [ see Appendix A ]
QUESTION ELEVEN: Should the Department impose a size or weight limitation for common domestic animals, even if the animal satisfies the "common domestic animal" prong of the proposed definition?
CADO supports the Department's current policy of not imposing a weight or size limit on service animals.
CADO believes a size or weight limit on common domestic animals such as assistance dogs would unfairly discriminate against individuals whose height, weight and / or the severity of their mobility impairment necessitates a match with an assistance dog of sufficient size and strength to prevent falls and perform other useful tasks without injury to the dog.
Additional Issue: RETENTION OF "DO WORK" IN THE NEW DEFINITION
We are pleased to see that the Department was receptive to CADO's educational efforts concerning individuals with psychiatric disabilities, autism and other mental impairments. It is our position that such individuals may significantly benefit from task trained service dogs and should not be lumped in with those who wrongfully claim that the ADA sanctions public access for them and their non task trained pets. CADO member programs have trained assistance dogs for individuals disabled by autism, Downs Syndrome, traumatic brain injuries, Alzheimer’s Disease, other cognitive issues and for an increasing number of persons with psychiatric disabilities. CADO indicated this in our 2007 meeting with the DOJ staff.
On behalf of the assistance dog movement, CADO hoped to create a better definition of service animals, one that would maintain a clear distinction between those animals which are individually trained to perform tasks to mitigate the effects of a disabling mental or physical condition and any animal whose mere presence or companionship provides emotional support or some other therapeutic physical health or mental health benefit. We hoped for a new definition that would end the confusion in the media, disabled community and the public and private sectors as to what qualifies an animal for the legal status of a service animal.
While there is much that is good about the proposed definition in the NPRM, a serious flaw has come to our attention. It concerns the Department's explanation titled "Task Emphasis" in the NPRM. The content is so contradictory to the Department's own interpretative guidance document, "Business Brief : Service Animals" from 2002 and to the intent of the proposed definition, which is to eliminate misunderstandings on what qualifies an animal to be a service animal, CADO must oppose the retention of the phrase "do work."
We refer to the statements: Tasks are by their nature physical, so the Department does not believe that such a change [ to physical tasks in the definition ] is warranted. In contrast, the phrase “do work” is slightly broader than “perform tasks” and adds meaning to the definition. For example, a psychiatric service dog can help some individuals with dissociative identity disorder to remain grounded in time or place. As one service dog user stated, in some cases “critical forms of assistance can’t be construed as physical tasks,” noting that manifestations of brain based disabilities such as psychiatric disorders and autism are as varied as their physical counterparts.
This discussion, giving grounding as the example of "do work" followed by the assertion that "in some cases, critical forms of assistance can't be construed as physical tasks," leads the reader to conclude that work is a form of assistance that is NOT a physical task. It suggests an animal will qualify as a service animal if a mentally disabled owner says the dog's presence or companionship helps to keep him or her grounded in time or place.
CADO is aware that for years, pet owners with psychiatric impairments have used the "my pet keeps me grounded" rationale for bringing their non task trained animal into places of public accommodation.
CADO is deeply concerned that this "do work" example will be cited in the future as proof that task training is unnecessary for animals belonging to people with a psychiatric, cognitive or mental disability. Certainly the idea that work can be a non physical form of assistance and not a task will further confuse the distinction between service animals and pets.
Therefore, in the interest of eliminating further confusion and abuse, CADO urges the Department to reconsider this "do work" issue. We respectfully point out the fact that the Department's own interpretative guidance in 2002 excluded the phrase "do work" from the way it defined a service animal. The updated guidance document reads:
"Service animals are animals that are individually trained to perform tasks for people with disabilities, such as guiding people who are blind, alerting people who are deaf, pulling wheelchairs, alerting and protecting a person who is having a seizure or performing other special tasks. Service animals are working animals, not pets."
The 2002 interpretative guidance on the ADA goes on to say: "Businesses may ask if an animal is a service animal or what tasks the animal has been trained to perform, but cannot require special ID cards.....etc."
For six years, the Department's own emphasis on the fact that Task Training is fundamental to the definition of a service animal in the Business Brief has been relied on by the disabled community, businesses, colleges and other interested parties. The DOJ has educated the public and businesses that the performance of tasks is the crucial distinction between specially trained service animals and other animals, whatever their label.
CADO posits that the “do work” phrase in the original definition had nothing to do with a non physical form of assistance. Rather, it merely reflected the fact it was customary to discuss the trained behaviors performed on command or cue by guide dogs as "guide dog work." Guide dog work is a series of trained tasks performed as needed, such as leading a blind person around obstacles, halting to indicate changes in elevation like a curb, avoiding traffic in the team's path, finding the location of a building's exit and finding an empty seat in a classroom or on a bus. These are trained tasks and stand in sharp contrast to the DOJ's example of the ambiguous concept of grounding.
Since 2002, the work performed by service animals has been task defined, arguably making the retention of "do work" and its given example of grounding in the proposed new definition confusing and easily misinterpreted. Unfortunately, due to the impression the average person receives from the NPRM discussion cited above, the phrase “do work” if defined by a term such as “grounding” will seriously undermine the Department's profoundly essential goal of distinguishing between service animals and pets whose presence or companionship will provide emotional support, therapy, comfort, or other therapeutic benefits. The controversy will never end.
Based on these considerations, CADO strongly recommends the elimination of "do work" in the final rule's definition. Failing that, we request illustrating the phrase "do work" with appropriate examples to eliminate the devastating consequences of using the ambiguous term “grounding” as an example. If the DOJ persists in using grounding, CADO feels it will most certainly undo all the progress accomplished by the 2002 interpretative guidance document in terms of educating the public, businesses and disabled community on this issue.
CADO wishes to thank the DOJ for its efforts to help clarify the issues which have created so much confusion and misinterpretation of the original service animal definition and regulations. We sincerely appreciate the opportunity to once again present ideas to the DOJ on behalf of CADO's numerous and varied constituencies made up of individuals who are disabled and partnered with service animals.
Sincerely,
Signature:
Joan Froling, Chairperson, International Association of Assistance Dog Partners
Signature:
Becky Barnes, President, Guide Dog Users, Inc
Signature:
Wells Jones, Chair of the Council of US Dog Guide Schools
Signature:
Darlene Sullivan, Board Member, Assistance Dogs International, North America
Appendix A
BEHAVIOR & TRAINING STANDARDS FOR ALL SERVICE ANIMALS
For over 75 years, assistance dogs have worked successfully in public and won the public's acceptance by achieving high behavioral and training standards, which set them apart from pets and other animals. In order to assure the comfort and safety of people with disabilities AND the general public, high behavioral and training standards must apply equally to all service animals. We propose that all service animals intended for use in public, regardless of species, be required to meet the same standards required of dogs specifically trained to assist people with disabilities. We are not proposing to disallow other species from service work. Any animal that can meet the existing standards for behavior, training, cleanliness and public appropriateness may be allowed to work in public when accompanied by the person for who's disability it was specifically trained.
These standards include:
PUBLIC APPROPRIATENESS:
* Animal is clean and does not have a foul odor.
* Animal does not urinate or defecate in inappropriate locations.
BEHAVIOR:
* Animal shall not make unsolicited contact with members of the general public.
* Animal's conduct does not disrupt the normal course of business.
* Animal works without unnecessary vocalization.
* Animal shows no aggression toward people or other animals.
* Animal does not solicit or steal food or other items from the general public.
TRAINING:
* Animal is specifically trained to perform more than one task to mitigate (lessen) the effects of its partner's disability; said disability being any
condition as described by and covered under the ADA that substantially impairs one or more major life functions.
* Animal obeys the commands of its handler.
* Animal works calmly and quietly on a harness, leash or other tether.
* Animal has been specifically trained to perform its duties in public and is accustomed to being out in public.
* Animal must be able to lie quietly beside the handler without blocking aisles, doorways, etc.
* Animal is trained to urinate or defecate on command
* Animal stays within 24" of its handler at all times unless the nature of a trained task requires it to be working at a greater distance.
Tired yet? I know I am. But hey, even if people don't agree with all that stuff, at least they can still make their own feelings known. Hopefully this results in clarification, no more pets running around where they shouldn't, and everybody who has legitimate service dogs, whether owner-trained or school-trained, getting the access they deserve.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
